Compare Filtering Technologies

This table compares software and hardware methods of filtering Internet content currently applied end users, ISPs and at Carrier level.

Technology

Effect on Network Performance

Typical

Application

Support

Requirements

Security

Ease of Implementation

Number of URLs blocked

Per User Cost

Effectiveness

Per user profiles

DNS Poisoning

None

ISPs, Carriers

Low

Med

Easy

Thousands

Low

Low

(minor overblocking risk)

no

IP address blocking

Low

ISPs

Medium

High

Medium

Thousands

Low

Low

(major overblocking risk)

no

PC-Based software

Medium

Homes

High

Low

Difficult


Millions

High

Medium

yes

Proxy-based web Filtering

Low-High

Corporate Networks

Medium

Very High

Medium

Millions

High

Very High

yes

Packet Inspection Appliance as Layer 2 Bridge

Low

ISP', Carriers

Medium

Very High

Medium

Millions

Medium


Very High

yes

Packet Inspection Appliance with mirrored/tapped traffic

None

ISP', Carriers

Medium

Very High

Easy

Millions

Medium


High

yes

Hybrid BGP and Packet Inspection Filter

None

ISPs, Carriers, Gateways, Hosted Systems

Very low

High

Very Easy

Thousands

Very low

High

No